—
—
How close are the top five?
The five elements whose range today’s long-term warming has gone furthest into. Each bar fills from the low end of the element’s range (0%) to the high end (100%); an element judged crossed by the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 is marked as such. Where this site measures something about the element, the line below the bar says what, and links to it.
Warming dial: 0 to 4 °C
Long-term global warming against pre-industrial, with the range in which each of the 16 elements could tip (Armstrong McKay et al. 2022).
—
Scroll sideways to see the full chart →
- Cryosphere (ice and frozen ground)
- Biosphere (forests and reefs)
- Ocean circulation
- Atmosphere (monsoons)
- Crossed (per Global Tipping Points Report 2025)
Each row is one tipping element, sorted by the low end of its range. The coloured bar is the range in which it could tip; the short dashed tick is the best estimate. The bold vertical line is long-term warming today. Orange and red dashed lines mark the Paris 1.5 °C and 2 °C limits.
The 16 tipping elements, one by one
Each gauge shows where today’s long-term warming sits against the element’s range, what this site measures about it (with a link to that page), what the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 says, and what tipping would mean. Green = below the range, orange = inside it, red = crossed.
- Likely tipping range (low–high temperature for this element)
- Scientists' best-guess threshold within that range (dashed)
- Long-term warming today
Cards with an orange tint are the six elements the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 puts closest to tipping: coral reefs, Greenland, West Antarctica, permafrost, the Atlantic overturning circulation and the Amazon. They come first.
Cascading tipping: how the systems connect
Tipping one system changes the odds for the next. Of the 20 interactions the Global Tipping Points Report 2025 assessed, most are destabilising. The chain below is the best-evidenced one: Greenland’s meltwater weakens the Atlantic overturning circulation, which moves the tropical rain belts (Wunderling et al. 2024). The review says cascades cannot be ruled out over centuries at 1.5–2 °C, and over shorter times above 2 °C.
Permafrost and methane
Permafrost thaw is one of the tipping elements above, and the slowest to show. Frozen Arctic ground holds about twice as much carbon as the atmosphere. This part shows what can be measured of it: methane in the air, worldwide and at Arctic stations, ground temperature in boreholes, and the carbon the region gains and loses.
Permafrost is carbon storage that thaws
The risk is not one sudden “methane bomb.” It is a frozen carbon bank becoming biologically active as the ground warms, deepens, slumps, and turns wet enough for microbes to make methane.
Methane in the air since 1983
Global mean methane — each bar is one month (US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Global Monitoring Laboratory). Cooler blues = lower mixing ratio vs the 1983–1990 baseline; warmer tones = higher.
Arctic flask stations vs reference (Mace Head)
Arctic stations consistently show more methane than the mid-latitude reference — local sources, wetlands, or transport from lower latitudes.
Global methane trend
Annual global mean from the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration — growth has re-accelerated since the mid-2000s.
Permafrost methane vs the whole budget
Each row is the world’s total methane emissions from all sources, about 575 million tonnes a year; the coloured slice is the northern permafrost region’s share, by two independent methods.
—
Where is permafrost warming fastest?
Scientists measure permafrost temperature in boreholes drilled 10 metres or more into the frozen ground. The first global comparison of these records, by Biskaborn and colleagues (2019), found the coldest permafrost warming fastest. Warming over 2007–2016, by permafrost type:
The longest-running boreholes, 1978–2016
Loading borehole records…
Why does this matter?
- Methane is about 80× more warming than carbon dioxide over 20 years — small atmospheric changes matter.
- The permafrost carbon has been frozen for tens of thousands of years; once microbes start releasing it, the warming feedback runs for decades.
- Continuous Arctic permafrost warmed 0.39 °C in a single decade (2007–2016), about twice the rate of global surface warming.
How does Arctic permafrost thaw affect you?
Pick a country to see how Arctic permafrost thaw reaches it…
What drives this
- Ocean heat →The climate system's main heat reservoir pushes ice, coral, and circulation risks.
- Global temperature →The dial itself: the long-term warming level the thresholds are compared with.
What this drives
- Sea-level rise →Greenland and Antarctic thresholds commit coastlines to centuries of change.
- Atlantic overturning →Circulation shifts can reshape rainfall, cold blobs, and regional climate.
- Coral reefs →One of the first major systems to enter danger bands near today's warming.
How we know this
- Warming level: long-term warming from our Global Temperature Monitor (Copernicus ERA5, the value of a 30-year trend at the latest month, the Copernicus method), copied each night. Beside it: human-caused warming from the Indicators of Global Climate Change 2025 and the last twelve months. NASA’s GISTEMP is downloaded nightly as a cross-check (its 1951–1980 anomalies plus 0.19 °C, NASA’s own conversion to 1850–1900).
- Thresholds: Armstrong McKay et al. (2022, Science), all 16 rows checked against the paper. They change only with a new assessment.
- Assessment: Global Tipping Points Report 2025 (University of Exeter, 160 authors, October 2025): the “crossed” judgement for coral reefs and the per-element notes, copied from its summary report. No newer edition existed in November 2026; the next global report is planned for 2027.
- Measured signals: from the other monitors on this site (coral heat stress, ice loss, the overturning circulation, the cold blob, Arctic winter ice, Amazon clearing, permafrost boreholes), each with its date and a link. Where this site measures nothing about an element, the gauge says so.
- Cascade evidence: Wunderling et al. (Earth System Dynamics, 2024), the review of how tipping elements interact, and the 2025 report’s interaction assessment.
- Cadence: tipping systems change over decades to millennia; this page is checked nightly but its inputs move monthly (temperature) to yearly (ice-sheet and permafrost studies).
- Uncertainty: the ranges are wide (the overturning circulation’s runs from 1.4 to 8 °C) and “inside the range” is not “tipped”. Definitions of a tipping point differ; we use Armstrong McKay’s temperature-range framing and the 2025 report’s judgements, and cite both.
- Permafrost and methane: methane from NOAA’s Global Monitoring Laboratory (global monthly average and Arctic flask stations), checked daily; borehole temperatures from GTN-P (to 2016, the service has not published newer data); permafrost status and the carbon balance from NOAA’s Arctic Report Card and published studies, as cited in each panel.
- Primary data & reading: Global Tipping Points Report 2025 · Armstrong McKay et al. 2022 · Wunderling et al. 2024 · Indicators of Global Climate Change 2025 · NASA GISTEMP · How this page is built